Ready to Start?

Stan McDaniels for US Congress

Here’s a conceptual framework for an Internet Bill of Rights focusing on freedom of speech, personal data protection, and private companies’ ability to moderate content:

• Freedom of Speech:
• Guarantee the right to express opinions and share information online without undue interference, akin to the protections afforded by the First Amendment in the U.S., but tailored for the digital realm.
• Ensure that this freedom does not extend to content that incites violence, constitutes hate speech, or breaches other legally recognized limits, like defamation or true threats.
• Personal Data Protection:
• Mandate that all internet users have control over their personal data, including rights to access, correct, delete, or transfer their data to another service provider.
• Implement stringent privacy laws requiring explicit, informed consent for data collection and use, with transparency about how data is processed and shared.
• Establish robust security measures to protect personal data against unauthorized access, breaches, and misuse, with clear accountability for data handlers.
• Private Companies’ Content Moderation with User Consent:
• Allow private companies to set content policies and moderate their platforms, but with an emphasis on transparency. Companies must clearly publish their rules and the rationale behind them.
• Require platforms to provide users with options to consent to or opt out of certain moderation practices, giving users control over their experience, e.g., choosing whether they wish to see potentially controversial content.
• Implement a system where users can appeal content moderation decisions, ensuring there’s a process for review and redress if content is removed or accounts are suspended.
• Encourage the creation of tools that allow users to customize their content exposure, thereby respecting individual preferences while maintaining the company’s right to manage its platform.

This framework aims to balance individual rights with the operational needs of private entities in the online space, fostering an environment where freedom of speech and privacy are protected while allowing for effective content governance with user involvement.

Here are additional elements that could be included in an Internet Bill of Rights to further protect users’ rights and enhance the online experience:

• Net Neutrality:
• Ensure that Internet Service Providers (ISPs) treat all data on the internet the same, preventing them from speeding up, slowing down, or blocking content based on its source, destination, or nature.
• Right to Anonymity:
• Protect the right of individuals to use the internet anonymously where legally appropriate, safeguarding against unwarranted surveillance or tracking.
• Access to Information:
• Guarantee access to a diverse range of information without undue censorship, promoting an open internet where knowledge is freely available across borders.
• Digital Literacy:
• Promote digital literacy initiatives to ensure that all citizens have the knowledge and skills to use the internet safely, effectively, and critically.
• Protection from Cyberbullying and Harassment:
• Establish clear legal guidelines and support mechanisms to protect users from online harassment, including cyberbullying, with provisions for both prevention and recourse.
• Universal Internet Access:
• Advocate for policies that aim to provide universal access to the internet, recognizing it as a basic utility necessary for participation in modern society, education, and commerce.
• Non-Discrimination:
• Ensure that the internet is a space free from discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, or other personal characteristics, both in terms of access and content.
• Fair Use and Copyright:
• Clarify the balance between copyright protection and fair use, promoting creativity, innovation, and education while respecting intellectual property rights.
• Transparency in Algorithms:
• Require platforms to be transparent about how algorithms influence what content users see, promoting fairness and reducing bias in content recommendation systems.
• Right to Disconnect:
• Acknowledge the right to disconnect from work-related communications outside of work hours, protecting personal time and mental health from the encroachment of always-on digital culture.
• Security and Infrastructure:
• Mandate that internet infrastructure be secure, resilient against cyber-attacks, and maintained to ensure reliability and availability.
• Accountability of Platform Governance:
• Establish oversight or regulatory bodies that can hold platforms accountable for their actions, particularly when it comes to content moderation, privacy breaches, or monopolistic practices.
• Interoperability:
• Encourage or require interoperability between different platforms and services to prevent vendor lock-in and promote a more competitive, user-friendly digital ecosystem.

These additions would aim to create a comprehensive framework where the internet serves as a tool for empowerment, innovation, and social good, while also protecting individuals from the potential negative aspects of digital interaction.